Top 5 Asphalt Roof Replacement Companies in Huntington, NY

Replacing an asphalt roof ranks among the biggest investments a Long Island homeowner will make, and the contractor doing the work matters just as much as the materials going on top. Huntington and the surrounding Suffolk County towns have plenty of roofing companies to choose from, but they don’t all install the same way, stand behind their work the same way, or bring the same level of care to a project. The five asphalt roof replacement companies in Huntington, NY listed below were chosen based on documented credentials, service area, and verifiable differentiators, not marketing copy.

What to Think About Before Calling Anyone

Asphalt shingle replacement isn’t a commodity job. Underlayment choices, flashing methods, ventilation planning, and fastener quality all affect how long a roof actually lasts, independent of which shingle brand goes on top. Before reaching out to any contractor, it’s worth knowing whether the company uses its own crews, who performs the estimate, what the warranty covers (labor vs. materials vs. both), and what cleanup looks like after the job wraps. Those details separate a 15-year roof from one that’s back in trouble in five.

Certifications from manufacturers like Owens Corning, GAF, and CertainTeed carry real weight here. Contractors with elite status, Platinum Preferred, Master Elite, and SELECT ShingleMaster, are vetted by the manufacturer and can offer extended warranties that standard contractors simply can’t.

The Ranked List

These five companies all serve the Huntington, NY area and have documented roofing operations on Long Island. Entries are ranked by overall fit for a homeowner seeking an asphalt roof replacement in this market.

1. Smart Choice Contracting

Smart Choice Contracting has been operating out of Huntington since 1999, with owner Mike Falco personally handling every estimate. No sales reps, no commissioned middlemen.

Where it fits: The company holds Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor status, one of only nine contractors on Long Island to carry that designation, which unlocks 50-year full labor and material warranties. They’ve completed 2,000-plus roof installations and report 1,600-plus satisfied property owners, with a 5.0 rating across 96 customer reviews. One detail that stands out: every job uses hot-dip galvanized nails, which outlast standard fasteners by roughly 15 years. A small material choice that compounds over time. Pricing is transparent with detailed estimates and no hidden fees, and the company offers 0% interest financing for five years through Service Finance, a 15% cash discount for customers paying in full, and discounts for active and retired military members and first responders. Emergency roofing services run 24/7 for leaks, storm damage, and similar urgent situations. Cleanup is handled thoroughly before the crew leaves.

2. Rapid Roofing

Rapid Roofing screenshot

Rapid Roofing is a locally owned Long Island operation with five offices spread across Nassau and Suffolk Counties, including locations in Syosset, Wantagh, Oceanside, Port Jefferson Station, and Bohemia.

Where it fits: They carry Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor status (the same manufacturer tier as the top pick) along with a BBB A+ rating and an Angi Super Service Award. Their asphalt shingle options include architectural shingles alongside premium designer lines, and their installation process addresses underlayment, ventilation, and flashing as distinct steps rather than an afterthought. Emergency repair services with rapid-response capabilities are available for storm and leak situations.

Worth checking: The multi-office model covers a wide geography, so confirming which crew and office handles a given Huntington project is a reasonable question to raise upfront.

3. Valorli

Valorli screenshot

Valorli, operating as Valor Roofing, serves 40-plus communities across Long Island including Huntington, with an emphasis on residential roof replacements and repair.

Where it fits: The company brings 30-plus years of experience and backs its work with a 30-year guarantee on all work performed, a meaningful commitment on the labor side. They complete most roof replacements within a single day, which limits disruption for occupied homes. Owner Tommy is noted across multiple reviews for personal involvement on projects, and the company offers free no-obligation roof inspections with a 24-hour response time for quote requests. Insurance claims guidance is also part of their process.

Worth checking: Valorli’s website and service documentation are less detailed on material certifications compared to contractors with manufacturer elite-status designations, so asking about which shingle lines they’re credentialed to install is a practical step.

4. Long Island Roofing

Long Island Roofing screenshot

Long Island Roofing & Siding is based in Ronkonkoma and has been serving Long Island for over 20 years, with Huntington listed among its covered communities.

Where it fits: The company uses its own crews on every project, no day laborers, and lists best-in-class warranties and flexible payment options as part of its offer. Beyond roofing, they handle siding, windows, and chimney work, which can be useful for homeowners coordinating multiple exterior projects at once. Monthly specials are available, and free estimates can be requested directly through their site. Customer testimonials highlight punctuality and professionalism.

Worth checking: The company markets across a broad Long Island footprint. Prospective customers in Huntington should confirm local crew availability and ask about the warranty terms in writing rather than relying on general language about “best warranties on Long Island.”

5. County Roofing

County Roofing screenshot

County Roofing was founded over 35 years ago and operates across Long Island, Queens, Massapequa, Smithtown, and Westchester under the same ownership and standards it started with.

Where it fits: They hold triple elite manufacturer certifications (GAF Master Elite, Owens Corning Platinum Preferred, and CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster), a combination carried by roughly 1% of contractors nationally. The company employs NRCA-trained installers directly, runs no subcontractors, and has founder Keith on-site for every project. They maintain an A+ BBB rating and 150-plus five-star Google reviews. Operations run 24/7.

Worth checking: County Roofing’s service area is wider than most on this list, covering multiple counties. Homeowners in Huntington should ask about scheduling lead times and confirm which office or team services their specific zip code.

How These Companies Compare at a Glance

Company

Manufacturer Status

Own Crews

Emergency Service

Smart Choice Contracting

Owens Corning Platinum Preferred

Yes

24/7

Rapid Roofing

Owens Corning Platinum Preferred

Not specified

Yes

Valorli

Not specified

Not specified

Not specified

Long Island Roofing

Not specified

Yes

Not specified

County Roofing

GAF Master Elite / OC Platinum / CT SELECT

Yes

24/7

Manufacturer certifications and direct-hire crews are two of the most checkable facts before signing anything. A contractor who can’t point to either is worth a harder look.

Bottom Line

Asphalt roof replacement companies in Huntington, NY run the gamut from large multi-county operations to owner-run shops where the person writing the estimate is the same one checking the finished work. What’s the right fit? It depends on what a homeowner cares about most, warranty length, manufacturer certification, direct owner involvement, or how fast the job gets done. Getting two or three written estimates, asking each contractor about fastener specs and underlayment choice, and confirming insurance and licensing before anything starts are steps worth taking no matter which company ends up on the roof.

You May Also Like